Find the help you need

Tell us a little bit about your legal needs and we'll put you in touch with one of our expert associates.

 
Contact Baker Newby

Plaintiff’s Award for Damages Reduced Substantially for Failure to Mitigate – Spurgeon v. Smith

posted by Luke Zacharias

This matter involves a motor vehicle accident which occurred on January 24, 2006.  Liability for the motor vehicle accident was not contested at the trial. 

 The Plaintiff suffered soft-tissue injuries to his neck, low back, and jaw, as well as headaches.  He was working as a mechanic at the time of the accident. 

The Plaintiff argued that his ability to work was substantially impaired by the motor vehicle accident.  The judge agreed that there was a loss in the Plaintiff's ability to work, however there was also a finding that he had not taken appropriate steps to pursue medical treatment and he had not pursued work opportunities as he should have. 

The Plaintiff's award for pain and suffering and past income loss were both reduced by 20% due to his failure to mitigate.  The Plaintiff's award for loss of earning capacity was reduced by 50% due to his failure to mitigate. 

The judge provided the Plaintiff with the following award: 

             Non-Pecuniary Damages                    $40,000.00

             Past Wage Loss                                       108,556.00      

             (less deductions for tax and 20% for failure to mitigate)

             Loss of Earning Capacity                    72,908.55

             Future Cost of Care                                4,594.00

             Special Damages                                     1,107.42

             TOTAL                                       $227,165.97

Have a comment? We would welcome your comments directly. lzacharias@bakernewby.com

BakerNewby

200 - 2955 Gladwin Road,
Abbotsford, BC V2T 5T4
Phone: 604-852-3646

Box 390, 9259 Main Street,
Chilliwack, BC V2P 6K2
Phone: 604-792-1376

21542 48th Avenue,
Langley, BC V3A 3M5
Phone: 604-534-1376